La Trattoria
524 Duval Street
305-296-1075
Website
"La Trat" as it's known to locals, is popular, busy and delicious.
The menu is extensive, featuring pastas, veal, fish and shellfish, along with chicken and meat options. White tablecloths, top notch service and an excellent selection of wines, combine with the food to make a satisfying dining experience you will want to repeat often.
I particularly like popping in for a martini or maybe even dinner at the bar, which offers popportunities for many interesting conversations and a great view of Duval Street (if you can find a seat).