729 Thomas Street
Blue Heaven is one of the most famous, most popular restaurants on the island. Some days, that means a 2 hour wait for breakfast. No matter, have a delicious Bloody Mary at the bar, browse the gift shop and watch the chickens prowl the open air seating area looking for crumbs dropped from plates. When you finally do get seated, the benedicts served with lime hollandaise are among the most popular selections. Lunch and dinner offerings include jerk chicken, yummy shrimp and local fish preparations, burgers and beef tenderloin. Whatever you do, save room for their truly famous Key Lime Pie, featured on both the Food Channel and the Travel Channel.